Impact of IPFC on Distance Protection of Multiline Transmission System | Open Access Journals

ISSN ONLINE(2319-8753)PRINT(2347-6710)

Impact of IPFC on Distance Protection of Multiline Transmission System

P.MaryJeyaseeli1, R.Gabriel Germans2
  1. PG Scholar Power Systems, Department of EEE, Velammal Engineering College, Chennai, India.
  2. Professor, Department of EEE, Velammal Engineering College, Chennai, India
Related article at Pubmed, Scholar Google

Visit for more related articles at International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology


Due to the development of Power Electronic devices, various FACTS devices such as STATCOM, SSSC, UPFC and IPFC are now installed in transmission line so as to improve the stability, voltage control and power flow control.Distance Relays are the unique devices which are used to protect the transmission line from various shunt faults. The reach of the distance relay is independent of the types of fault when compared to the over current protection.When a FACTS device, say, IPFC is incorporated in order to enhance the power flow control, voltage control, etc., on existing transmission line, it will result in significant change in impedance. This in turn will lead to mal operation of distance relay, as the Distance Relays are sensitive to apparent impedance seen by the relay and zones.This paper analyses the impacts of IPFC in apparent impedance seen by the Distance relay for various shunt faults.


IPFC, Distance Relay, Multiline system, Reach of the relay, FACTS, Power system protection


FACTS devices are being incorporated in the transmission lines in order to control the power flow and to ensure stable operation of the system. Various FACTS devices such as SVC, TCSC, STATCOM, UPFC are used in practice. Regarding the multiline system, the best suited FACTS device for power flow control is IPFC.On the other hand the adoptability of these devices with the conventional relaying system should be ensured. The optimal setting for the relay operation to coordinate with the FACTS devices are discussed [2] to overcome the undesired effects of their operation together. More specifically the effect of UPFC [4], STATCOM [5] SSSC [6] are discussed.


The IPFC scheme provides, together with independently controllable reactive series compensation of each individual line, a capability to directly transfer real power between the compensated lines. This capability makes it possible to equalize both real and reactive power flow between the lines; transfer power demand from overloaded to under loaded lines; compensate against resistive line voltage drops and the corresponding reactive power demand; increase the effectiveness of the overall compensating system for dynamic disturbances. In other words, the IPFC can potentially provide a highly effective scheme for power transmission management at a multiline substation.
Figure.1 Basic two inverter IPFC
Table 1. Operation Logic for Relay
The relayhas tocompute the impedancea s seen fromitslocationandcompareitwithsetvaluetotakethetrip decision.Becauseofthesimpleseries model ofthe faulted line, the line impedanceisdirectlyproportionalto the distance of fault .Hencethe namedistancerelay.Sucharelayiscalledunderimpedancerelay. Inpractice, however,the wordunder isdropped andthe relay is simplycalledimpedance relay.Itis possibletosynthesizeseveral morecomplicated distinct relay. Todistinguishthisrelay from theotherdistance relays, it is called as simple Impedance relay.The positive sequencecomponent is the only component which is presentduringall faults. Thus, it would be prudentto measure positive sequence impedance between the relay location and the fault soas to cater for everyfault.
Phase Faults
Ground Faults
Figure 3.Equivalent circuit for Ground fault
aroundtheloopformedbytheseriesconnection o fthethree sequencenetworks,
Thefirst stepofdistance protection is,therefore,set toreach up to80to90%of theline section. In this zone the relay should operate instantaneously a n d there is no intentionaltimedelay. Thesecondstep isrequiredinorder t o provide primaryprotectiontothe remaining 20% to10%ofthe line, which isleft outofthefirst step. In addition, i t isset tocoverupto 50%ofthe nextlinesection.
Operatingtime ofstep II=Operatingtime ofstep I +Selective t ime interval.
Where, Selectivetimeinterval = CB operatingtime +Relayover-traveltime
When therearemorethan oneadjoining lines, thesecondstep shouldextend upto 50% into the shortest adjoining line.The third step is provided with an intensionto givefull back-up to the adjoining line section. I t covers the line section under consideration,100%ofthenext linesectionand reaches furtherintothe system. The motivationbehind the extended reach ofthis step istogivefullback-uptothenext linesection inspiteofthemaximum under-reachofthethird step.


Single circuit, 400 kV, horizontal configuration, line is considered for the simulation. The system consists of two transmission lines and resembles the multiline system with IPFC configuration. In this figure, the IPFC is connected between the prime and the test transmission lines. The IPFC structure is realized by connecting two Static Synchronous Series Compensators in both the lines and adjoining them at the common dc link. The performance of relays for different fault types, fault locations, and fault resistances is analyzed to show the impact of VSC-based IPFC on distance protection of the multiline system. Faults are realized at 300th km in the test line with the per-unit distance from the relay location. In this sense, it has a value between 0.5 and 1.0 for faults between and in the sample system.For the calculation of apparent impedance seen by the relay, symmetrical components are used. The system taken here has the fault to the right of IPFC in order to show the significant effect of IPFC.
The parameters for the system considered are given below.
Fundamental frequency = 50 Hz
Positive sequence Impedance = 1.7431+19.4i Ω
Zero sequence Impedance =2.6147+4.8862i Ω
MVA Rating = 2000 MVA
Positive sequence Impedance = 0.8716+9.71i Ω
Zero sequence Impedance = 1.3074+2.4430i Ω
MVA Rating = 2000 MVA
Transmission Line Data
Configuration = Horizontal
Number of sub conductor = 2 No‘s.
Height of the conductor from ground = 15 meter
Phase to Phase distance = 11 meter
Diameter of the conductor = 3.18 cm
Bundle space = 45.72 cm
Length = 450 km
Positive sequence Impedance:
Simulations are performed on system compensated by IPFC on 300th km of transmission line which is shown in figure. 5.1. Firing angle of both shunt and series converters are fixed for the sake of simplicity and analyzed the impedance of transmission line seen by the Relay. Where the voltage and current measured at Relay point is digitized at the frequency of 10 kHz & the digitized data were fed to the Fourier series block which converts the time domain data into Phase domain data. The processed data then given to the Relay unit which is designed based on the equation already derived. In order to evaluate the impact of impedance in a single step, constraints are incorporated in simulation.
Figure .4Impedance seen by the relay for L – G fault
In figure.4 and figure.5, duration of 0.0s to 0.8s shows the impedance of the system measured at relay location for the uncompensated line.In which from 0.5s to 0.6s, L-G and L-L faults are respectively introduced for the duration of 5 cycles (i.e. 100 ms). In response to the fault the system voltage is reduced and the fault current is increased.From 0.8s to 1.4s IPFC is incorporated where the impedance measured is slightly decreased compared to the impedance of previous uncompensated line with no fault. The amount of reduction in Impedance is subject to the firing angle of VSC‘s.Once again the same fault is introduced from 1.0s to 1.1s. Now the comparison can be made with the impedance obtained for the uncompensated & IPFC compensated line. Result shows that the impedance with IPFC is large compared to the impedance without IPFC. Hence the impedance falls out of zone1 for the fault within zone1, which indicates the over reach of relay.
Table. 2 Impedance values for various shunt faults
For analysis L-L fault falls under Zone 1 is considered which contains positive sequence impedance. Positive sequence Impedance of the line is


A multiline test system of 400 V, 50 Hz is designed. It is compensated by the incorporation a of six pulse VSC based IPFC unit, realized by adjoining two SSSCs at the dc link. Using MATLAB/Simulink conventional distance relay unit is designed and it is fed by the necessary voltage and current measurements in order to calculate the fault impedance. Various shunt faults are fed to the system at its 300th km. The apparent impedance seen by the relay is calculated at conditions of before and after compensation by IPFC. It is concluded that the incorporation of IPFC in the multiline system affects the actual fault impedance that should be seen by the relay. This effect is due to the injection/absorption of real/reactive power by the IPFC on the multiline system. As a consequence the perturbation in the actual fault impedance forces the relay to mal operate and thus the relay under reaches or over reaches.
Thus the undesired effects introduced by the incorporation of IPFC on the distance protection of multiline system isanalyzed.


[1] MojtabaKhederzadeh,, ―Impact of VSC based Multiline FACTS controllers on Distance protection of Transmisson Lines, IEEE transaction on power delivery, volume 27, no.1,Jan 2012

[2] P.K.Dash,et,al., ―Adaptive Relay setting for Flexible AC Transmission systems(FACTS), IEEE Transaction on Power Delivery, vol.15, no.1, Jan 2000

[3] F.A.Albasri,, ―Performance comparison of distance protection schemes for shunt FACTS compensated transmission lines, IEEE Transaction on Power Delivery, vol.22, no.4, pp.2116-2125,2007

[4] X.Zhou,et,al., ―Performance evaluation of a distance relay as applied to a transmission system with UPFC, IEEE transaction on Power Delivery, vol 21,no.3, pp.1137-1147,2006

[5] Khalil El-Arroudi,et,al., ―Operation of Impedance Protection Relays with the STATCOM, IEEE Trans. On Power Delivery, vol.17,no.2,Apr 2002

[6] M.M. Saha,, ―First zone algorithm for protection of series compensated lines, IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol.16,no.2,pp.200-207,Apr 2001

[7] R.Leon Vasquez-Arnez,et,al., ―A noval Approach for Modelling the steady state VSC based Multiline FACTS controllers and their Operational Constraints, IEEE Trans. On Power Delivery, vol.23,no.1, pp.457-464, Jan 1998

[8] A.G.Phadke, T.Hlibka, and M.Ibrahim, ―Fundamental basis for distance relaying with symmetrical components, IEEE Trans.Powerapp.Syst. Vol.PAS-96, pp. 6354-646, Mar/Apr 1997.

[9] D.L.Waikar, S.Elangovan , and A.C.Liew, ―Fault Impedance estimation Algorithm for Digital Distance Relaying, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 1375–1383, Jul. 1994.

[10] K.K.Sen, ―SSSC—Static synchronous static compensator: Theory, modeling, and applications, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 241–246, Jan. 1998