Complexity, Heterogeneity and Mutational Analysis of Antibiotic Inactivating Acetyl Transferases in MDR Conjugative Plasmids Conferring Multi-Resistance | Open Access Journals

E- ISSN: 2320 - 3528
P- ISSN: 2347 - 2286

Complexity, Heterogeneity and Mutational Analysis of Antibiotic Inactivating Acetyl Transferases in MDR Conjugative Plasmids Conferring Multi-Resistance

Asit Kumar Chakraborty*, Mitali Maity, Sabuj Patra, Suchismita Mukherjee and Tanmoy Mondal

Department of Biochemistry & Biotechnology, Oriental Institute of Science & Technology (OIST), Vidyasagar University, West Bengal, Midnapore-721102, India

*Corresponding Author:
Asit Kumar Chakraborty
Deprtment of Biochemistry & Biotechnology
Oriental Institute of Science & Technology (OIST)
Vidyasagar University, Midnapore- 721102 India
Tel: +91-9339609268
E-mail: chakraakc@gmail.com

Received date: 24/04/2017; Accepted date: 08/05/2017; Published date: 20/05/2017

Visit for more related articles at Research & Reviews: Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology

Abstract

Drug acetylating transferases (aac) are enzymes that inactivate aminoglycoside antibiotics by acetylating its O- and N- atom in the drug. aac genes were detected in bacterial plasmids and integrons of many pathogenic bacteria rendering drug resistance. The unique CAT enzyme was discovered early that could acetylate chloramphenicol at 1’ and 3’ –OH group and largely used as reporter gene in expression vectors. Aminoglycoside 6’-N-acetylating enzymes were mainly classified as acc6’-Ia to aac6’-If and genes were designated as aacA1 to aacA8 but aacA16 or aacA41 types isomers were also sequenced. The isomers aacA3, aacA4 and aacA8 are very identical contrary to other aacA1 isomers. Aminoglycosides 3’-acetylating enzymes were designated as aac3’-Ia to aac3’-Xa and genes were designated as aacC1 to aacC10. Sequence analysis suggested that aac2’, aac4’ and bifunctional enzymes (aac6’-aph2’’) were different class of acetylating enzymes. But aac6’-1b-cr protein that was involved in ciprofloxacin resistance resembled to aac6’-1b with point mutations. Interestingly, cat gene has no similarity to aacA1 or aacC1 genes and so far was ignored as being non-clinical origin. But now catB3 gene was reported in many MDR plasmids of pathogens like Shigella flexneri (pR100), Yersinia pestis (pIP1202), Escherichia coli (pNR1), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (pOZ176), Klebsiella pneumoniae (pNDM-MAR) and Salmonella enterica (pHXY0908). Such plasmids were also frequently associated with acc3’ and aac6’ enzymes including diverged ß-lactamase genes (blaTEM, blaNDM, blaCTX-M etc) and drugs efflux genes (acrAB, mexAB/ CD/XY, tetA/S) as well as AG adenyl transferases (aad) and AG phospho transferases (aph) genes. Surely, appearance of cat, amp, tet genes in conjugative plasmids of superbugs is frightening as those genes are randomly used in expression vectors for RDT work. Diversities among drug acetylating enzymes were found very high suggesting multiple mechanisms of their origin.

Keywords

Drug acetyl transferases, Antibiotic pollution, mdr genes evolution

Introduction

The MDR is a unique phenomenon where bacteria acquire MDR genes in plasmids and chromosomes and can survive in stressful environment containing high concentration of antibiotics and other pollutants [1]. Such bacterial infections, on the other hand are hard to cure by antibiotics contributing huge life and wealth loss worldwide [2]. Aminoglycoside acetyl transferases modify the drug’s structure by acetylating its N-atom or O-atom in the drug and as a result such acyl-drug could not bind the target site to inhibit bacterial replication, transcription or translation [3-8]. So patient could not get rid of bacterial infections by simply taking few tablets of ampicillin, streptomycin or gentamycin antibiotics because acetyl transferases were activated in plasmids that inactivate drugs.

The AMR mechanisms broadly classified into six major categories: (1) activation of β-lactamase (bla) (2) activation of drug modifying enzymes (aac, aad, aph) (3) activation of drug efflux genes (acr, tet, cmr, mex) including ABC drug transporter (4) alteration of target sites by mutations (rRNA, PBPs) (5) neutralizing antibiotic after binding with drug like tetM and (6) lower expression of porins restricting drug entry like imipenem. Thus it is very complex to stop gene creation in nature under stressful environment and none could even imagine such changes how created an acute problem in medicine today [9].

The first acetylating enzyme was discovered as cat gene or chloramphenicol acetyl transferase. Chloramphenicol was first discovered in actinomycete isolated from soil by Ehrlich in 1947 followed by Tamura in 1971 from Streptosporagium viridogriseum. Chloramphenicol inhibits the bacterial 30S ribosome and is a very good antibiotic as it cures the common diseases caused by S. aureus, E. coli, K. pneumoniae, and more. However, soon cat gene was discovered in many bacterial pathogens those were found resistant to chloramphenicol [10]. Cat enzyme is different from “amp” or “tet” gene’s mode of actions in that it acetylates the chloramphenicol drug (1’ and 3’ positions) in such a way that acetylated drug no longer able to bind the bacterial ribosome. Thus cat gene containing bacteria (in plasmid) easily grow containing MIC amount of chloramphenicol in vitro as well as in vivo in patient blood [11,12].

Sequence analysis suggested that cat gene was a different enzyme in amino acid sequence than aacA1or aacC1 and other isomers. Why cat gene was not considered as aac enzyme was not sure to say but aacA1 enzymes are linked to clinical origin found in MDR plasmids with other MDR genes like blaTEM, strA/B, sul1/2, tetA/S type genes including Tnp and Tra genes [13-15]. So cat gene (designated as catB3 and was very famous for CAT in vitro transcription technology) was isolated from small R-plasmids in bacteria that were not clinically relevant [10]. However, it was detected now in many large conjugative plasmids of common pathogenic bacteria [16].

Similarly, aac(6’) enzymes was symbolized as aacA1 to aacA9 but other isomers like aac(3’) designated as aacC1-aacC9 [17-20]. aac2’’ and aac4’ etc were kept aside and their divergence was labelled as aac(2’’)-Ia/b/c or aac(2’)-I/II etc [21-23]. Similarly, there are catB2/4/8 or catA_1/2 isomers in the literature. Mutations of cat gene as well as aacC1 and aacA1 genes were never investigated as compared to huge citations of β-lactamases mutations (blaTEM, blaOXA, blaCTX-M etc) that conferred PDR or XDR type resistance in bacteria [10]. The origin of this review however, lies on the facts that GenBank data analysis of aacA1/C1 genes contradicted highly for consensus primers that to be used to study the contamination of superbugs in Kolkata water bodies, particularly Ganga River water.

Results

Similarities among cat gene isomers

GenBank data analysis clearly suggested that cat genes were widespread in bacterial plasmids and integrons (Tables 1-4). Class I integron mediated catB3 genes of many bacteria like 2177bp IntI1 integron of Pseudomonas aeguginosa (AN:EF660562); 2731bp Class I integron of Escherichia coli (AN:ABP35557), 5857bp class I integron of Klebsiella oxytoca, 2297bp Class I integron of Acinetobacter baumannii (AN:ADF59078), 1738bp Class I integron of Aeromonas veronii (AN:ALB07153), 4632bp In846 integron of Enterobacter cloacae (AN:AGJ70489) and that of Proteobacteria (AN:WP_000186237) were identical in protein sequence [11]. Interestingly, such integrons were also linked to other type’s aminoglycoside acetyl transferases like aacA1, aacA4 and aacA7 [12].

Classification of drug modifying aac(6’) N-acetyl transferases  
Gene Synoname AA length Accession no. Protein ID Plasmid/ Bacteria Associated MDR Genes
  aacA1 Aac6’ 185aa AB061794 BAB72153 pCMXR1/ E. coli Sul1, blaCMY-9
Aac6’ 185aa AB116723 BAD11027 Inlt-1/ K. pneumoniae blaGES-4
Aac6’-Ia 185aa AB901039 BAO48019 Intl-1/ P. aeruginosa blaIMP-10
Aac6’ 185aa NC_014167 YP_0036573222 pJA144188/ C. resistens aphA, strA/B, sul1
Aac6’-Ia 185aa M18967 AAA98298 Intl/ Citrobacter diversus nd
Aac6’-Ii 182aa L12710 AAB63533 Intl/ Enterococcus facium nd
aacA2 Aac6’-1b 199aa JN420336 AEB82864 pNDM-MAR/K. pneumoniae OXA-1,
CTXM-15
aacA3 aac(6’) 184aa KM111260 AIP98294 Intl-1/ P. aeruginisa nd
    aacA4 aac6’ 184aa EF138817 ABO21792 Intl-1/P. aeruginosa blaVIM-3, sul1
Aac6’ 184aa EF488369 ABP35556 Intl-1/ E. coli catB3,
Aac6’ 184aa HM043570 ADH82126 Intl-1/ K. pneumoniae cmlA1
aac6’ 184aa JN596279 AEZ05102 Intl-1/ K. oxytoca blaGES11, sul1
Aac6’-Ib 201aa M55547 AAA98404 Intl-1/ P.
aeruginosa
nd
Aac6’-IIa 184aa M29695 AAA25688 Intl/ P. aeruginosa nd
Aac6’-1b 210aa GQ2933500 ADC80825 23kb plasmid cmlA, blaTEM-24
Aac6’-IIb 180aa L06163 AAA25680 Intl/ P. aeruginosa nd
Aac6’-Ic 146aa M94066 AAA26549 Intl/ S. marcescens nd
Aac6’ 172aa KF977034 AHY00029 pDW16C2/ K. pneumoniae blaVIM
Aac6’ 172aa KP870110 AKC98300 pRCPEC6335-2/ E. coli blaC-5, blaTEM1
aacA5 aac6’ 158aa AM749810 CAO78542 Intl-1/ P. aeruginosa blaVIM-2
Aac6’ 158aa HQ005291 ADN22946 Intl-1/ P. aeruginosa blaVIM-2, dhfr
aacA6 Aac6’-Ib 172aa AY686225 AAT94163 Intl-1/ A. xylosoxidans blaVIM-2
    aacA7 Aac6’ 152aa KJ679405 AID65189 Intl-1/ P.
aeruginosa
OXA-2, aadA6
aac6’-1a 152aa EF577406 ABQ65124 In58/ P.
aeruginosa
blaVIN-2
Aac6’ 152aa FJ715943 ACN62402 Intl-I/P. aeruginosa nd
Aac6’ 152aa KJ679406 AID65194 IntI1/P. aeruginosa blaVIM-2, aacA4
Aac6’ 152aa JX486753 AFV31445 In 58/C. fruendii blaVIM-2, aacA4
aac(6’)-I1 152aa KP754008 ALE32150 In 903/P. aeruginisa Sul1
Aac6’ 152aa KJ679405 AID65190 IntI1/P. aeruginosa blaOXA-2. aadA6
Aac6’-I1 152aa U13880 AAA90937 Intl-1/ E. aerogenes nd
aacA8 Aac(6’) 172aa KJ679405 AID65187 IntI1/P. aeruginosa OXA-2, aacA6/7
Aac6’-IIb 180aa L06163 AAA25680 Genomic/P. fluorescences ANT(3’)-Ia
Aac(3’) 308aa AXTL01000004 ESD46433 Genome/Escherichia coli nd
      aacA9 ? Aac6’’-Ic 146aa M94066 AAA26549 Intl/ Serratia marcescens nd
Aac6’-If 144aa X55353 CAA39038 Intl/ Enterobacter cloacae nd
Aac6’-Ig 145aa L09246 AAA21889 Intl/ Acinetobacter sp nd
Acc6’-Ij 146aa L29045 AAC41392 Intl/ Acinetobacter sp nd
Aac6’-Ik 145aa L29510 AAA87229 Intl/ Acinetobacter sp nd
Acc6’-Im 173aa Z54241 CAA91010 Intl/ Citrobacter freundii nd
Acc6’-Is 146aa AF031327 AAD03491 Intl/ Acinetobacter sp nd
Acc6’-Iq 183aa AF047556 AAC25500 Intl/ K. pneumoniae nd
Aac6’-Iw 146aa AF031331 AAD03495 Intl/ Acinetobacter sp nd
Aac6’-Ix 146aa AF031332 AAD03496 Intl/ Acinetobacter sp nd
Aac6’-Iy 145aa AF144880 AAF03531 Intl/ Salmonella enterica nd
Aac6’-Iz 153aa AF140221 AAD52985 Intl/ S. maltophila nd
aacA16 Aac6’-Ip 173aa Z54241 CAA91010 1153bp Intl/Citrobacter nd
AacA17 Aac6’-Iq 183aa AF047556 AAC25500 plasmid/ K. pneumoniae nd
aacA28 Aac6’-Iae 183aa AB104852 BAD14386 Plasmid/ P. aeruginosa blaIMP,
aadA1
aacA30 Aac6’-I30 184aa AY289608 AAP43642 2220bp Intl/S. enterica blaOXA-53
aacA39 Aac6’-Iai 188aa EU886977 ACI28880 pLQ1001/P. aeruginosa aadA1, Sul1
aacA41 Aac6’-Iaf 183aa AB462903 BAH66386 Intl123/P. aeruginosa blaIMP, sul1
aacA42 Aac6’-33 184aa GQ337064 ACT99625 6816bp/P. aeruginosa blaGES,/OXA-2
aacA43 Aac6’-Ii 182aa L12710 AAB63533 Intl/Enterococcus faecium nd

Table 1: Classification of major AAC(6’) acetyl transferase; The accession numders of plasmids, integrons and genomic fragments carrying aac(6’)-type genes were demonstrated. The different types of pathogenic MDR bacteria and associated mdr genes were also described.

Classification of different amino glycoside 3’-aceteyl transferases (aacC1)
Aac3’ Genes Enzyme types No of AA Accession
number
Protein Id
 number
Plasmid/genomic Name of bacteria
  aacC1 Aac3’-Ia 177aa X15852 CAA33850 pR1033(Tn1696 Enterobacteriaceae
Aac3’-Ia 154aa AY577724 AAT51721 3035bp genomic A.
baumannii
Aac3’-Ia 176aa L06157 AAA88422 genomic P. aeruginosa
Aac3’-I 154aa KJ688704 AID61151 2684bp genomic K. pneumoniae
Aac3’-I 154aa AJ009820.2 CAA08847 6436bp pSEM S. enterica
Aac3’-Ia 154aa KR028107
ALD03719 
2427bp genomic A.
baumannii
Aac3’-I 154aa JX486753 AFV31447 3030bp In58 integron C. fruendii
      aacC2 Aac3’-IIa 286aa JQ364967 AFI72859 87kb pGuE-NDM E. coli
accC2 286aa X54723 CAA38525 R plasmid E. coli
Aac3’-IId 286aa EU022314 ABS70977 Plasmid fragment E. coli
Aac3’-IIe 286aa EU022315 ABS70978 Plasmid fragment E. coli
Aac3’ 286aa JN202624 AFP55521 pFZ51; 15672bp H. parasiuis
Aac3’ 311aa AXUL01000144 ESA99429 2663 bp genomic K pneuminiae
Aac3’ 286aa KJ187752 AJD77170 pTR2 K. pneumoniae
Aac3’-III* 286aa HF545433 CCN79846 pE66An E. coli
Aac3’-III* 286aa NC_024983 YP_009061951 pSTm-A54650 S. enterica
Aac3’ 286aa KP010147 AJN91221 pECO-HN; 18784bp E. coli
Aac3’ 286aa JX988621 AFZ84485 pNDM-OM K. pneumoniae
Aac3’ 286aa HQ840942 AES85952 pSRC27-H; 50129bp S.
enterica
    aacC3 aacC3 286aa X13543 CAA31895 Plasmid pWP113a Enterobacteriaceae
Aac(3’)-III 208aa JMVN01000059 KDG46702 5980bp genomic E. coli
Aac3’-IIIa 271aa X55652 CAA39184 2336bp genomic P. aeruginosa
Aac3’-IIIb 245aa L06160 AAA25682 2613bp genomic P. aeruginosa
Aac3’-IIIc 279aa L06161 AAA25683 1234bp genomic P. aeruginosa
Aac3’-III 308aa ADTS01000075 EGB89811 genomic E. coli
Aac3’-III 308aa AXTL01000004 ESD46483 6803bp genomic E. coli
Aac3’-III 294aa LO017738 CRH08791 143kb pRCS57 E. coli
  aacC4 Aac3’-IV 261aa X01385 CAA25642 1368bp genomic E. coli
Aac3’-IV 255aa MPWC01000123 OKB98731 genomic K. pneumoniae
Aac3’-IV 172aa AJ009820.2 CAA08845 pSEM S. enterica
AAC3’ 206aa CP015500 ANE70283 Genome K. pneumoniae
Aac3’ 227aa FLCN01000053 SAT62391 Genomic fragment K. pneumoniae
aacC5 aac(3’)-Vb 269aa M97172 AAA26548 1572bp genomic S. marcescens
  aacC6 Aac(3’)-VI 299aa M88012 AAA16194 2077bp genomic E. cloacae
Aac3’-VIa 274aa nd WP_031611451 nd E.
coli
Aac3’-VI 300aa nd WP_053271189 nd E. coli
Aac3’-VI 299aa nd WP-020837048 nd S. enterica
  aacC7 Aac3’-VIIa 288aa M22999 AAA88552 1494bp genomic S. rimosus
Aac3’-VIIa 288aa AJ749845 CAG44462 genomic S. rimosus
Aac3’-IIb 286aa GG657754 EFL26570 genomic S. himasstatinious
  aacC8 Aac3’-VIIIa 286aa M55426 AAA26685 1353bp genomic S. fradiae
Aac3’-VIIIb 287aa nd WP_063840271 nd S. ribosidificus
aacC9 Aac3’-IXa 281aa M55427 AAA25334 1149bp genomic M. chalcea
Aac3’-IXb 279aa KB405056 EMF57573 genomic S. bottropensis
  aacC10 Aac3’X-Ia 284aa AB028210 BAA78619 genomic S. griseus
Aac3’X-I 284aa FMCP01000318 SCE16679 genomic Streptomyces sp
Aac3’X-I 284aa FLTQ01000010 SBU98351 genomic Streptomyces sp

Table 2: Classification of major AAC(3’) acetyl transferase; The accession numders of plasmids, integrons and genomic fragments carrying aac(3’)-type genes were demonstrated. Protein ids and types of MDR bacteria were also described.

Types of aac2’ and aac4’ acetyl transferases
  AAC2’ aac(2’)-I 181aa NC_000962.3 NP_214776 Genome M. tuberculosis
aac(2’)-Id 210aa U72743 AAB41701 Genomic fragment M. smegmatis
Aac2’’-IC 181aa CP012506.2 ALB17378 Genome M. tuberculosis
aac-2’ 198aa CWKH01000002 CVZ16866 genomic M. neworleansense
AAC-APH hybrid acetyl transferases-phospho transferase
  AAC-APH aacA-aphD 479aa AB682805 BAM15583 6483bp genomic S. aureus
aacA-aphD 479aa GZU565967 AAA88548 pSK1 S. aureus
aacA 479aa AP003367 BAB47534 pVRSAp; 25107bp S. aureus
Aac6’-aph2’ 479aa M13771 AAA26865 2120bp integron  E. faecalis
Aac6’-aph2’’ 479aa CP002120 ADL66016 2924344bp genomic; nt 2111743-2113182 S. aureus
Type of CAT genes or chloramphenicol acetyl transferases
      CAT catB3 210aa EF516991 ABP52023   E. coli
catB3 210aa HX259086 AAD20921 pHSH2 E. coli
catB3 210aa DQ343904 ABC69169 1406bp integron M. morganii
catB3 210aa HQ170516 ADX02581 3735bp integron A. media
catB3 210aa KM278198 AIX48179 2208bp integron V. fluminis
catB3 210aa JX885645 AGM38586 13241bp genomic S. enterica
catB3 210aa KC237285 AGM38599 9983bp plasmid S. enterica
catB3 210aa KX421096 AOR05996 253kb plasmid pA32 S. enterica
catB3 210aa EF488369 ABP35557 2731bp integron E. coli
catIII 213aa JN202624 AFP55523 pFZ51; 15672bp H. parasuis
catB4 182aa AP012056 BAN19548 pKPX-2 K. pneumoniae
catB8 210aa KC543497 AGL46467 pOZ176 P. aeruginosa
catA1 219aa AP012055 BAN19276 pKPX-1 K. pneumoniae
catA1 219aa KJ541071 AIV96857 pG5A4Y217 E. coli
cat_2 219aa LN850163 CRK62815 pI1-34TF E. coli
catB2 210aa AF047479.2 AAC14737 pNR79 E. coli

Table 3: Localization of cat genes and hybrid aac-aph genes. Popular cat genes in plasmids/integrons of pathogenic MDR bacteria were described with GenBank accession numbers and protein ids. Also activated hybrid aac-aph genes were described including less well known aac2’ and aac4’ type genes that destroy many aminoglycoside antibiotics.

Multi-drug resistant genes in Plasmids involving aac and cat genes
Accession number Plasmid Size MDR Genes profiles with one or more aac and cat genes in large bacterial conjugative plasmids GenBank Year Pathogenic bacterial name
CP015725 210 aacA4, blaOXA1, cat, arr2, sul1, aph2’, mrx, mph2’, blaNDM1, ANT3”, dhfr, blaTEM1, RND, ANT3”-Ia, ble, blaCTXm-65, floR(MFS), sul1. Aac3’-IVa 2016 S. enterica
KF793937 61 tetA, blaOXA-30, catB3, aac6’-1b-cr, arr3, sul1, SAPa, QnrB4, blaDHA, mex, mphA(2’’), aphA1(3’) 2016 K. pneumoniae
KM877269 249 Sul1, aphA1, aadA1, cmlA, aadA2, floR, hph, aac3’-IV, aac6’-1b-cr, , blaOXA1, catB, arr3, sul1, terA/C/F 2015 S. enterica
LO017736 124 tetA, aac3’-Ib, blaOXA-1, aac6’-Ia, blaCTX-M-15, blaTEM1, ABC 2016 E. coli
LO017738 143 tetA, blaTEM1, blaCTX-M-15, aac3’-III, cat, bla OXA-1. Dhfr, mrx(2’’), mphA, ABC 2016 E. coli
LN794248 300 Sul1, strA/B, blaTEM1, tetA, aac6’-Ib, blaOXA1, catB3, aacC3, tmrB, blaCTXM-15, aadA1, catA1 2015 S. enterica
KF954759 73 blaKPC-3, strB, aac6’, chrB, ncrA/Y, srbA 2014 K. pneumoniae
KX421096 253 OqxB/A RND, sul1, dhfr, fosA3, sul2, aac3’-Iva, aac6’-1b-cr, blaOXa1, catB3, arr3, sul1, TerC/D/A 2016 S. enterica
AB61665 47 blaIMP--2, aacA4, aadA2, tetA, blaCTXm, sul1 2012 K. pneumoniae
KC354802 41 aacA4, aadA1, blaOXA-9, blaTEM-1 2013 K. pneumoniae
NC_021087 26 blaGIM-1, aacA4, aadA1, blaOXA-2, sul1 2015 E. cloacae
NG_035843 15 blaOXA-30, catB3, arr-3, sul1, qnr, blaDHA-1 2014 E. coli
LN555650 299 terF, sul1, strA, catB, blaACC-1, aacA4, blaVIM-1 2015 S. enterica
JN420336 267 blaNDM1, blaOXA1, aac6’, qnrB1, catB, blaCTX-M, 2012 K. pneumoniae
KC543497 501 Ter2, sul1,, MFS,, blaIMP-9, ble, catB8, aac6’-IId 201 6 P. aerogenosa
NC_022078 317 ABC, merB, cat, aph*, aac3’, cmr, tetA, blaKPC 2015 K. pneumoniae
JQ64967 87 aad, sul1, blaNDM1, aac3’-II, blaOXA1, aac6’-1b-cr 2016 E. coli
AP012056 141 Aac3’, aac6’, catB4, tetA, sul2, blaOXA/CTX, strB/ 2016 K. pneumoniae
CP011634 227 blaOXA, aad*, blaTEM, merC, sul1, aac 2015 K. oxytoca
NC_010795 15 Sul1, aacC2, catB3, strA, blaROB-1 , aph3’-I 2014
  1. p-pneumoniae
CP009116 95 Aph, blaTEM, aac3’, MFS, dhfr, aad, arr2, blaNDM1 2014 K. pneumoniae
NC_019889 87 Aac3’-II, blaNDM1, sul1, MsrE, mphE 2014 K. pneumoniae
AP012055 250 blaNDM1, ccdA/B, aadA2, catA1, qacA1 2013 K. pneumoniae
KF250428 151 blaIMP-4, aacA4, MerC, cmr, floR 2013 K. pneumoniae
HG530658 223 blaACC-1, strA, aadA2, aac3 2015 E. coli
NC_019375 180 blaVIM, aacA7, dhfr, ANT3’, blaSHV-5, sul1, aph3’ 2014 P. stuartii
KF705205 134 hph, strA, aac3’-IV, tetA, blaTEM-1 2015 S. enterica
NC_022522 168 blaCTX-M-25, aacA4*, strB, strA, aadB, blaOXA-21 2014 S. enterica
LC055503 160 blaSHV-12, aac6’, blaOXA-10, aadA1, sul, blaDHA 2015 K. pneumoniae
HG941719 135 blaTEM/CTX/OXA, aadA5, mphA, aac6’, sulI, tetA 2014 Escherichia coli
KJ541071 44 sul1,
blaOXA-2, aadA/B, blaTEM, catA1, blaGES-5
2014 E. coli
GU256641 110 sul2, strA, blaTEM, blaSCO, aacC2, blaACC-4 2011 E. coli
KJ541681 90 tetA, sul1, aadA1, aac3’-Ia, aac6’-Ib, aadA2,
blaSHV5
2015 K. oxytoca

Table 4: Characteristics of large MDR conjugative plasmids carrying multiple aac and cat genes. Chloramphenicol acetyl transferases, AG acetyl transferases and other mdr genes were clustered in one plasmid and bacteria carrying such plasmid were usually XDR and PDR types. Further, mutations in gyrAB, 16S rRNA, porB and ABC genes have not been analyzed here.

We observed that cat genes were now associated in conjugative plasmids which were hard to rescue in absence in drugs and also could deliver MDR genes into household bacteria. So it seems AMR is a ubiquitous phenomenon in modern days. As for example, in conjugative MDR plasmid (pI1-34TF; 167198bp) of Escherichia coli (AN: LN850163) four acetylating enzymes had been accumulated in four positions of plasmid spreading all across same distance. Two cat genes (cat_1 and cat_2; protein Ids. CRK62767 and CRK62815) were different where cat_2 was catB3 type but cat_1 was related to xenobiotic acetylating enzyme. Moreover two other acetylating enzyme, N-6 hydroxylysine 0-acetyl transferase (protein id. CRK62680; antibiotic_NAT-like) and SPBe2 prophage derived acetyl N-3’-transferase (yokD; protein Id. CRK62756) had roles in inactivating diverse drugs. Such plasmid did contain other mdr genes like blaOXA-1, blaTEM-1, macB (macrolide exporter), MFS, aph (phosphotransferase), aad3’ (streptomycin adenyl transferase), tetA (tetracycline transporter) and tmrB (tunicamycin resistant protein). Further, such plasmid also accumulated HTH-type cmtR and envR, tetR transcription factors in close association with IS-elements and transposons. Multi-align and seq-2 sequence analysis were presented in Figures 1 and 2 where catB3 was found similar but catB8 had many mutations and frequent carboxy-terminal deletions and substitutions [14].

microbiology-biotechnology-Acetylation-choramphenicol

Figure 1: Acetylation of choramphenicol by CATB2 plasmid transfection of HeLA cells with Lypofectamine reagent (panel, A). Lane, 1 free chloramphenicol, lane 2, cell extract with no plasmid, lane 3, 5 μl cell extract and lane 4, 10 μl cell extract with transfected plasmid. Structures of 3-acetylated chloramphenicol (panel-B), N-acetylated ciprofloxacin (panel, C) and tabromycin (panel, D).

microbiology-biotechnology-CAT-Enzymes

Figure 2: Homologies among CAT Enzymes: (A) CatB3, catB4 & CatB8 similarities. (B) catA2 and CatA4 similarity and (C) catB3 vs. catA_1 similarity.

catB3 gene was present in many MDR plasmids including 249kb Samonella enterica plasmid pHXY0908 (AN:KM877269) and in high molecular weight P1 plasmid of Klebsiella pneumoniae containing mphA (macrolide 2” phosphotransferase; protein Id. WP_000219391), aadA2 (ANT3”-1a), aph3’-1a (protein Id. WP_000018329), GCN5 acetyl transferase (protein Id. WP_003026803) and phosphonothricin acetyl transferase (protein Id. WP_004152096) including other mdr genes like drug transporter tetA/tetG, ABC transporter (protein Id. WP_004118832), MFS-type drug efflux proteins (protein Ids. WP_003846917 and WP_000214125) as well as CTX-M-24/KPC-2/VEB-3 types β-Lactamases. Similarly pOZ176 large plasmid (AN:KC543497) contains catB8a, neo (aminoglycoside 3’-O-phosphotransferas; protein Id. AGL46257) and aac6’-IId (aacA4-type) giving resistance to chloramphenicol, neomycin and amikacin respectively [16,24].

Similarities among the aac(6’) isomers (aacA1-aacA8)

Aminoglycoside 6’-N-acetyl transferase actively acetylates 6-N atom of amikacin, kanamycin, and neomycin [25-30]. BLAST analysis suggested that aacA1 was unique enzyme and had no similarity to aacA2/3/4/5/6 but aacA3 has similarity to aacA4 and aacA8 lineages (Figure 3 and Table 1). Two types (184aa and 172aa) of aacA4 enzyme contained difference in NH2 terminal 13 amino acids indicating a precursor. Aminoglycoside 6’-N-acetyl transferases (aacA1) were located in plasmids and integrons of E. coli and other Enterobacteriaceae and were identical sequence [31-36]. As for example, plasmid NR79 (8298bp) of E. coli had aacA1 including aadA3, catB2, and sul1 genes. Another 8049bp small plasmid pCMXR1 contains blaCMY-9 and sul1 mdr genes with aacA1. However, in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, aacA1 gene was located in class I integron In831 with blaIMP-10 that involved in imipenem resistance. All aacA1 sequences were identical and no mutation was found. Pseudomonas aeruginosa class I integron contains aacA3 gene (protein Id. AIP98294 and AN:KM111260). A conjugative MDR plasmid, pNDM-MAR (267242bp, AN:JN420336) of Klebsiella pneumoniae contains aacA4 gene (protein Id. AFB82784) along with deadly blaNDM-1 and blaCTX-M-15 genes (Table 4) [37]. Another aacA4 gene (AN:ABP35556) was located in 2731bp class I integron (AN: EF488369) of E. coli with closely linked to catB3 gene [38]. Two aacA4 genes (accession nos. AEZ05099) were located in 6061bp small plasmid pINCan01 (AN:JN596279) of Klebsiella oxytoca in association with blaGES-11 and sul1 mdr genes [39]. Two genes for aminoglycoside acetyl transferases (aacA5 and aadA7) were located in Pseudomonas 2903bp class I integron in association with blaVIM-2 and dhfr genes, involved in carbapenem and trimethoprim resistance respectively [40-44]. Two aminoglycoside 6'-acetyltransferase type Ib (aac6’-1b; 172aa) were cloned from Achromobacter xylosoxidans (AN:AY686225) as 3436bp class I integron with also blaVIM-2 gene. A 281 amino acids aacA8 gene was found with aacA7 (152aa) isomers in 3608bp class I integron (AN:KJ679405) of Pseudomonas aeruginosa associated with aadA6 and blaOXA-2. There was no similarity between aacA1 vs. aacA4 of Klebsiella pneumoniae (protein Id. ADH82126) and Escherichia coli (Protein Id. BAB72153) or Pseudomonas aeruginosa (protein Id. AIP98294) and therefore Pseudomonas enzyme designated as aacA3 which was isolated in China (Figure 2 and Table 1). Neither 172aa 6’-N-acetyl transferase (aac6’-1b; protein Id. CAF18332) of Morganella morgani has similarity to aacA1 and designated as aacA4 and such enzyme in both plasmids were identical suggesting horizontal transfer but Klebsiella plasmid (AN:HM043570) was partially sequenced (38-44). The few new aminoglycoside resistance gene, designated aac(6')-Iae, encoded a 183-amino-acid protein that shared 57.1% identity with AAC(6')-Iq. Such Escherichia coli expressing exogenous aac(6')- Iae showed resistance to amikacin, dibekacin, isepamicin, kanamycin, netilmicin, sisomicin, and tobramycin but not to arbekacin, gentamycin or streptomycin (Figure 1 and Tables 1-4) [45].

microbiology-biotechnology-terminal-truncation

Figure 3: Similarities among aacA1 enzymes: (A) aacA1 vs. AaacA4 with terminal truncation with point mutations. (B) aacA1 vs. aacA5 with internal deletions and no similarity. (C) No similarities among aacA5, aacA6 and aacA8 and (D) no similarity between aacA5 vs. aacA6.

Similarities among aac(3’) acetyl transferases;

Aminoglycoside 3’-N/-O--acetyl transferases were isolated from various microorganisms where it was found both in plasmids and chromosomes [46-55]. aacC1 enzyme was isolated from 2324bp plasmid R1033 of many Enterobacteriaceae and were aac(3)’- 1a type (AN:CAA33850) [46]. aacC2 (EC:2.3.2.81) of Escherichia coli was cloned from a Moscow isolate (AN:X54723; Protein Id. CAA38525) [47]. A 310 amino acids length Escherichia coli aac3’ enzyme (protein Id. ESD46483) was isolated in genome fragments (Accession nos. AXTL01000004 and ADTS01000075). Pseudomonas aeruginosa aac(3’)-1b enzyme was 176 aa and likely partial (protein Id. AAA88422) [48]. aacC3 isomers (aac3’-IIIa/b/c) were cloned from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (ANs. X55652, L06160 and L06161) [49] and aac3’-Vb was sequenced from Serratia marcescens genomic fragment and the enzyme had 72% similarity to aac3’-Va and gave high label resistance to gentamycin, netimicin and moderate resistance to tobramycin (protein Id. AAA26548) [53]. Similarly, aac3’-VIa gene (AN:M88012) was cloned from Enterobacter cloacae large plasmid with 39% and 48% similarities to aac3’-VII and aac3’-II respectively [51,52]. Similarly, aac3’-VIa enzyme was found 299 aa (protein Id. AAA16194). aacC7 (protein Id. AAA88552), aacC8 (protein Id. AAA26685) and aacC9 (protein Id. AAA25334) genes were isolated from Streptomyces rimosus (AN:M22999), Streptomyces fradiae (AN:M55426) and Micromonospora chalcea (AN:M55427) (Figure 3 and Table 2) [53,54]. AAC(3)-XI, a new aminoglycoside 3-N-acetyltransferase from Corynebacterium striatum was isolated recently [55].

Similarities among 2’’ acetyl transferases

An Acinetobacter baumannii aac2’’ acetyl transferase (286aa; protein Id. AAA21890) was identified [56]. Also a chromosomally encoded aminoglycoside 2'-N-acetyltransferase (AAC(2')-Ic) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis was isolated [57-61]. Similarities among aac6’-1b-cr enzymes that mediates fluoroquinolone resistance. Aminoglycoside acetyltransferase, AAC(6')-Ib reduces the activity of ciprofloxacin by N-acetylation at the amino nitrogen on its piperazinyl substituent [62]. AAC(6′)-Ib-cr differs from AAC(6′)- Ib, by two specific codon exchanges Trp102→Arg and Asp179→Tyr, which have been found to be necessary and sufficient for the ciprofloxacin resistance phenotype [63]. Among 313 Enterobacteriaceae from the United States, aac(6′)-Ib-cr was detected in 15 (32%) of 47 E. coli isolates, 17 (16%) of 106 K. pneumoniae isolates, and 12 (7.5%) of 160 Enterobacter isolates [64]. ESBL Escherichia coli were isolated from poultry farm in Switzerland associated with fluoroquinlone resistance due to aac6’-Ib-cr acetyl transferase. Aac6’-1b-cr enzyme present in pKPS30 plasmid (AN:KF793937; nt. 22991-23509) of Klebsiella pneumoniae [65]. Enterobacter aerogenes isolates associated with variable expression of the aac(6')-Ib-cr gene was reported giving high label fluoroquinilones resistance [66]. A Korean study indicated the presence of aac(6’)-1b-cr variant enzyme in E. coli and K. pneumoniae and few strains simultaneously contained aac(6’)-1b and aac6’-1b-cr with resistant to tobromycin, kanamycin and amikacin (Figure 1) [66]. Other mechanisms for fluoroquinolone resistance were target protection by qnrA1/B1/S1 proteins (has high affinity for ciprofloxacin) and active drug efflux by QepA and OqxAB pumps (remove ciprofloxacin from bacterial cytoplasm) [63]. Salmonella enterica plasmid also detected aac6’-1b-cr gene (AN:KM877269; nt. 119381-119965, complement).

Similarities among bifunctional (aac-aph) drugs acetylating enzymes

Discovery of Enterococcus facium aac6'-aph2’’ bifunctional aminoglycoside modifying enzyme in 70 kb plasmid containing transposon Tn5281 and IS256 element was phenomenon [67]. All E. facium strains from United Kingdom had showed high level gentamycin resistance with many MDR genes and multiple conjugative plasmids were detected as demonstrated by Pulse- Field Gel Electrophoresis (PFGE) and hybridization studies [68-71]. A French study isolated Staphylococcus aureus strains with aminoglycoside resistance and had both aac6’-aph2’’ hybrid and aph3’-III genes (phospho transferases) located chromosomally [40]. A turkish study with 358 genetamycin resistant Staphylococcus aureus showed 334 aac-aph type bifunctional acetylating enzyme [72]. A US-study indicated high level aminoglycoside resistance in Enterococcus fecalis due to aac6’-aph2’’ enzyme causing both gentamycin and streptomycin resistance but streptomycin resistance conferred due to other aph3’-III/aph5’’-III type genes [73]. Shigila sonnei genome has aac6’-aph2’’ bifunctional enzyme (protein Id. CSO06978) with similarity to aacA4 enzyme (EC:2.3.1.82) of Proteus vulgaris (protein Id. WP_058127929), Escherichia coli (protein Id. CRL66321), Acinetobacter johnsoni (protein Id. ALV74709) or Pseudomonas aeruginosa (protein Ids. CBI63199, CBL95252 and ALI59095). Entercoccus faecalis chromosome islands carried bi-functional acetyl transferases (aacA-aphD; protein Id. ANN02929), streptothricin acetyl transferase (Sat4; Protein Id. ANN02919) including many adenyl tramsferases (Protein Ids. ANN02918, ANN02921, ANN02922 and ANN02927), streptomycin phosphotransferase (aphA3) and ISA(E) gene that conferred resistant to pleuromnticin, streptrogramin and incosamide antibiotics [74]. Bifunctional aminoglycoside-modifying enzyme like aminoglycoside (6')acetyltransferase-Ie/ aminoglycoside 2″-phosphotransferase-Ia (AAC(6')-Ie-APH(2″)-Ia) from Gram-positive cocci, (was isolated that conferred resistance to the 4,6-disubstituted aminoglycosides kanamycin, tobramycin, dibekacin, gentamycin, and sisomicin, but not to arbekacin, amikacin, isepamicin, or netilmicin [75]. A recently discovered bifunctional antibiotic-resistance enzyme named AAC(3)-Ib/AAC(6')- Ib', from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, catalyzes the acetylation of aminoglycoside antibiotics. The AAC(3)-Ib domain appears to be highly specific to fortimicin A and gentamicin as substrates, while the AAC(6')-Ib' domain exhibits a broad substrate spectrum [76-79].

Similarities of drug acetylating enzymes with strA/B and other phospho transferases

strA and strB genes could inactivate the streptomycin by phosphorylation. Phospho-streptomycin could not bind bacterial ribosome and such bacteria could grow at as high as 100 μg/ml streptomycin giving AMR [80]. Sequence analysis suggested there was no similarities between catB3 vs. strA/B and aac6’/3’ vs. strA/B. The aminoglycoside phosphotransferase (aph gene) phosphorylate the antibiotics so that phosphorylated kanamycin, amikacin and neomycin could not kill the bacteria. There was also no similarity between AG acetyl transferase (aacA1/aacC1) with 264aa neomycin phosphotransferase (aph3’-Ia, Protein Id. CAA23892) and 341aa hygromycin phospho transferase (hygA, protein Id. AHC55481). However, streptomycin phosphotransferases (strA, 278aa and strB, 276aa; protein Ids. AAA26443 and CED95338) have only 28% similarities within 72% and 37% cover respectively [81,82]. Similarity of dug acetylating enzymes with drug adenylation enzymes. The aminoglycoside adenyl transferase [EC:2.7.7.47] was present in many bacterial plasmids of diverse bacterial species of Escherichia (ANs:HG41719, KJ484637, KM377239), Klebsiella (ANs:KF914286 and KF719970), Salmonella (AN:JQ899055) and Acinetobacter (AN: KM401411), but also present in some bacterial chromosome as in Salmonella enterica [83].

Antibiotic adenyl transferase (~263aa) adenylate drugs at 6-N position and conferred bacteria resistant to aminoglycoside antibiotics like streptomycin and amikacin [84]. Such enzymes seem Rel-Spo-like super family and do not have much similarity to the AG 3’/6’ N-acetyl transferases and catB3 enzyme. Interestingly, adenyl transferases have similarity across the species and also notably exists as different isomers (aadA1 to aadA17) with 50-80% sequence similarities among itself [85,86].

Similarities of drug acetylating enzymes with β-lactamases

Beta-lactamases are very diverged enzymes with at least twenty distinct isomers including TEM, OXA, NDM1 and CTX-M [1]. Metallo β-lactamases (VIM, IMP, NDM1, SPM, GIM, DIM) are very deadly as resistant to imipenem and beta-lactamase inhibitors cavulinate and sulbactam [10]. BLAST analysis found no similarities between AG acetyl transferases and β-lactamases [87].

Conjugative plasmids have multiple drug acetylating enzymes

GenBank (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) search indicated (Table 4) that each single conjugative plasmid carried multiple drug acetylating enzymes (cat, aac) in association with many beta-lactamase genes as well as strA/B, sul1/2 genes (10). As for example, Salmonella enterica plasmids (pIncH12 and pHXY40908) accquired four (aac6’-1b, catB3, aaC3, catA1) and three (aac3’-IV, aac6’-1b-cr, catB3) drug acetylating enzymes (accession nos. LN794248, KM877269). Table 4 profoundly indicated how seriously multiple mdr genes had gathered in plasmids of many common pathogens that no drug would work to cure such bacterial infections.

Chromosomal localization of drug acetyl transferases

A 143aa long acetyl transferase was isolated from A. baumannii (AN:JFWP02000007; nt. 103508-103939) with similarity to aac6’-like enzyme (protein Id. EXT17036). Acinetobacter genomospecies aac6’-Ir enzyme (protein Id. WP_063840327) has 79% similarity to aac6’-Is (protein Id. AHD03491) but aac6’-It, aac6’-Iw, aac6’-Ix and aac6’-Iu have 83%, 85%, 90% and 94% similarities to aac6’-Is respectively (protein Ids. WP_063840329, WP_005296085, ALB75422 and WP_063840330) [88,89]. Aeromonas hydrophila genome (AN:LNUR01000009; nt. 843037-843495) has an unique 152aa 6’-acetyl transferase with limited similarity (47%) to aac6’-Ih of A baumannii (protein Id. ALB75422). Pesudomonas saponiphila genome (AN:FNTJ01000001; nt. 257741- 258187) also has148aa long 6’-acetyl transferase (protein Id. SEB43247) with 51% similarity to A. baumannii aac6’-Ih enzyme (protein Id. ALB75422).

Chromosomally located AAC(2')-Ic of Mycobacterium tuberculosis catalyzes the coenzyme A (CoA)-dependent acetylation of the 2' hydroxyl or amino group of a broad spectrum of aminoglycosides. The aac(2')-Ic gene was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, and was purified. Recombinant AAC(2')-Ic was a soluble protein of 20,000 Da and acetylated all aminoglycosides substrates tested in vitro, including therapeutically important antibiotics like tobramycin, amikacin, kanamycin and ribostamycin. MRSA bacteria were initially discovered as methicillin resistant microbe named Staphylococcus aureus gram positive circular bacteria that notoriously known as for skin infections. The methicillin resistance gene (mecA) encodes a methicillin-resistant penicillin-binding protein and activated with mobile genetic element, the staphylococcal cassette chromosome mec (SCCmec), of many MRSA isolates which also associated with bla, aac, aad, ANT and sul1/2 types MDR genes. Such multi-drug resistant bacteria are susceptible only to glycopeptides antibiotics such as colistin and tigicycline [90,91]. Mutations among CAT enzymes catB3 gene has no similarity to chloramphenicol drug efflux gene cmlA (protein Id. AKG90151), or acetyl transferases (aac3’- IV; Protein Id. AKG90173) or kanamycin phosphotransferases (protein Id. AKG90144) or hygromycin phosphotransferase (protein Id. AKG90172). No mutations were reported among the class I integron mediated catB3 genes of many Enterobacteriaceae (see, ANs: EF660562; ABP35557; ADF59078; AGJ70489). However, 217 aa long Proteus mirabilis CAT enzymes (protein Ids. WP_049194799 vs. WP_049197252) had two point mutations (V24A, N130D) and 201 aa long CAT enzymes in Escherichia coli had two point mutations (Y16N, D195N) and 9aa NH2-terminal substitutions (protein Ids. WP_050436713 vs. WP_050558894)

Mutation among aacA1 type enzymes

We see seven mutations in Aeromonas hydrophila aac6’-I enzymes (ANT67440 vs. KWR67119) with 95% similarities. However, 26 mutations in Aeromonas piscicola aac6’ enzyme (protein Id. KWR67119) at the NH2 -termianl 60 amino acid region (WP_065401184 vs. KWR67119). A 194aa long aac6’-Ia enzyme of Wohlfahrtiimonas chitiniclastica has 9aa signalling peptide at the NH2 terminus and very similar to aacA1 enzyme of E. coli plasmid pCMXR1 (AN:AB061794) except one point mutation (V84I). But 185 aa E. coli aacA1 enzyme (protein Id. BAB72153) has only 55% similarity with 185 aa long Klebsiella pneumoniae aac6’-Iai enzyme (protein Id. WP_032495046). Such unusual aacA43 enzyme has two different mutations in A. baumannii ((I2S, K141N; protein Id. WP_024437351) and P. aeruginosa (R20Q, R95K; protein Id. WP_071846376).

Several mutations in many Enterobacteriaceae aacA4 enzymes (aac6’-1b type) were reported with respect to Escherichia coli enzyme (protein Id. ABP35556). Different point mutations were found in Pseudomonas aeruginosa (A75G; protein Id. WP_071846301), (S83G; protein Id. WP_071846385) and (T132A, K133R; protein Id. WP_071593232). Similarly in E. coli aacA4 enzyme, a single mutation (Q101L; protein Id. WP_069985732) was reported and also in Enterobacter hormachei (R181C; protein Id. WP_07220113) and in Pseudomonas putida (Q49R; protein Id. WP_071984682). A 197aa long aacA4 enzyme (protein Id. AKJ19116) in P. aeruginosa plasmid pMRVIM0713 (AN:KP975076) had extended 13 aa and two mutations (M1V and S102L) were reported. Such NH2-terminal fusion were found frequently as in P. aeruginosa integron-mediated 203aa long aac6’-1b enzyme (protein Id. AAC46343; AN:U59183) and also in 210 aa long enzyme (protein Id. CBI63203; AN:FN554980). A chromosome mediated Acinetobacter baumannii 216aa long aacA4 enzyme (protein Id. EKA73751) with similar M1V and S102L mutations was also reported (Figure 3).

A 183aa long aacA16 N(6’)-acetyl transferase (protein Id. WP_001109644) has only 60% similarity with aacA43 enzyme of many Enterobacteriaceae (protein Ids. WP_063840279; WP_024437351). Such enzyme has 60% similarity with the Citrobacter freundii aac6’-I1 enzyme (protein Id. CAA91010; AN:Z542441) with most divergent at the NH2-terminus. As such enzymes have only 55-65% similarity with the aacA1 enzymes (protein Id. BAB72153), their association in aac6’-I class was not therefore justified (>60 mutations).

Mutations among aacC1 type enzymes

AacC1 enzyme of Enterobacteriaceae is 177 amino acids (protein Id. CAA33850) and has similarity to Acinetobacter baumannii gentamycin N-3’-acetyl transferases having different mutations reported in different isolates: In one isolate (protein Ids. WP_031950771, EXD70625 and WP_000441892) with three mutations (R98K, P102A, T175P). In Pseudomonas aeruginosa, aacC1 enzyme has many mutations reported. As for example, one isolate has S23R, K74R, D83E mutations (protein Id. WP_052158612); in another K38Q, D83E, E165D mutations (protein Id. WP_063840256) and in another (protein Id. ALE32149) five mutations (K38Q, D83E, R98K, P102A, and E165D) with few common mutations. However, less conserved enzymes have 71-73% similarities (protein Ids. ABN10340 and CRQ60998). Salmonella enterica aacC1 enzyme (protein Id. WP_032491356) has three mutations with two very common (S104I, R98K and P102A) and in another, two mutations were detected (P152T, S81I; protein Id: WP_032491356). An A. baumannii and P. aeruginosa AAC(3)-I enzyme have P152T common mutation (protein Ids: WP_052133400 and WP_063840258).

E. coli 158aa long AAC3’-acetyl transferase has two mutations (A53G, R234Q) that induces apramycin resistance (protein Id. WP_064756331) and also in K. pneumoniae (W5L, A53G; protein Id. WP_064735602). But in another E. coli mutant three mutations (A53G, H241R, G246E ; protein Id. WP_072833186) and in another four mutations (A53G, K177N, L178C, D182E; protein Id. WP_072739411) were reported. AAC(3)-I enzyme of Serratia marcescens (178aa; protein Id. OCO95380) and Enterobacter cloacae (178aa; protein Id. WP_032663836) have only 73% similarity with 22aa signalling protein at the NH2 terminus suggesting those enzymes are diverged aac3’-Ia type. Even both enzymes are 178aa long with 88% identity, have 22 mutations demonstrating drug acetyl transferases are indeed involved rapidly similar to β-lactamases (Figure 4).

microbiology-biotechnology-Sequence-alignment

Figure 4: Sequence alignment of different AAC3’ drug acetyl transferases. ESD46483 (E. coli chromosomal aacC1 protein, 308aa, AN:AXTL01000004); AAA21890 (A. baumannii aacC2 protein, 286aa; AN:M62833); CAD27711 (E. coli aacC4 protein, 261aa, pHK11-apra vector; AN:AJ438947); CAA33850 (Enterobacteriaceae plasmid mediated aacC1 protein, 177aa: AN:X15852); CAA38525 (E. coli aacC2 protein, 286aa; AN:X54723); CAA39184 (P. aeruginosa aacC3, 271aa; AN:X55652); AAA26682 (P. aeruginosa aacC3b protein, 245aa; AN:L06160); AAA25683 (P. aeruginosa aacC3c protein, 279aa; AN:L06161); AAA26548 (C. marcescens aacC5b protein, 269aa; AN:M97172); AAA16194 (E. cloacae aacC6 protein, 299aa;AN:M88012); AAA88552 (S. rimosus aacC7 protein, 288aa, AN:M22999); AAA26685 (S. fradiae aacC8 protein, 286aa; AN:M55426); AAA25334 (M. Chalcea aacC9 protein, 281aa; AN:M55427); BAA78619 (S. greseus kan gene. 284aa, AN:AB028210).

The 286 amino acids length Escherichia coli aacC2 (protein Id. CAA38525) was found similar to aac(3’)-IIc enzyme of E. coli (protein Id. WP_063840266) but no similarity to aacC1 enzyme. Escherichia coli aacC2 enzyme (protein Id. AFI72859) had four (L14F, H275Q, E276K) and ten mutations (T11L, R12Q, K78E, P84L, A162T, N194D, E204D, A268P, A274V, Q278E) with the similar aac3’-IId (protein Id. ABS70977) and aac3’-IIe (protein Id. ABS70978) enzymes respectively. Among the Enterobacteriace aac3’-II enzymes several mutations were reported (T87A, A112T, T132S, A245V; see Protein Ids. WP_00988063; WP_051421733; KTQ31168). In Salmonella enterica enzyme 4bp deletion and T132S mutation were reported (protein Id. WP_060588432). No mutation was found between K. pneumoniae and E. coli aacC2 enzymes (AGP03376 vs. ODH13880). Other aac(3’)-II enzymes reported in Klebsiella pneumoniae and Acinetobacter baumannii were shown very similar mutations indicating a horizontal transfer of such genes from E. coli plasmid by conjugation. The mutations in K. pneumoniae (protein Ids. AGP03376 and WP_031944095) were; L11I, Q12R, R70L, T79A, R183W, S193R, D204E, T270A, V277A, E279Q, and C280R. The mutations in A. baumannii (protein Ids. WP_057690920 vs. WP_002063884) were E142K, G184V, D186X but with Escherichia coli plasmid-mediated aacC2 enzyme (protein Id. CAA38525) 14 mutations were reported (L11I, Q12R, R70L, T79A, K135E, R183W, V184G, Y186D, S193R, D204E, T270A, V277A, E279Q, and C280R). In Enterobacter sp strain 50858885 similar mutations were reported as follows: L11I, Q12R, R70L, K78E, K135E, T79A, P84L, K135E, R183W, S193R, T270A, V277A, E279Q and C280R. Although Shigella flexneri (protein Id. ADY02606) had very similar mutations but much more mutations (only 76% similarity) were found in Salmonella enterica enzyme (protein Id. WP_061873001) and 85% similarity to Sinorhizobium melilti (protein Id. WP_003525983) aac3’-II enzyme.

However, numerous mutations were reported in aac(3’)-III enzymes (EC:2.3.1.81) of E. coli conjugative MDR-plasmid pRCS57 (143225bp; AN:LO017738) as follows: L11I, Q12R, R70L, T79A, K135E, R183W, S193R, D204E, T270A, V277A, E279Q, and C280R (protein Id. CRH08791). Such plasmid has also had mrx macrolide resistant protein, mphR repressor, blaTEM-1 and tetA tetracycline efflux protein as well as Tnp and Tra genes including many IS-elements. Interestingly. a 308aa aac3’-III-like E. coli enzyme (protein Id. EGB89811) had extended 9aa at the NH2 terminus and very similar to other Enterobacteriaceae 294aa aac3’- III enzyme (protein Id. WP_013023858).

An 172aa long aacC4 enzymes of E. coli (protein Id. ACS75040) and P. aeruginosa (protein Id. AGG23542) were found two mutations R107Q, D170S and M54L, D170S respectively. Stenotrophomonas maltophila had D170M point mutation (protein Id. ABN48565; AN:EF210035). Acinetobacter baumannii genome had reported 210aa 38aa N-terminal extended aacA4 enzyme with D170S, O171V mutations. Citrobacter freundii plasmid pMRVIM1012 had 34aa N-terminal extended aacC4 enzyme with L90S, D170S mutations. Achromobacter xylosoxidans 19.8kb plasmid mediated 210aa aacA4 enzyme (protein Id. BAV17747) had also similar mutations (L90S, D170S). Similar mutation further reported in Serratia marcescens class-3 integron 188aa long aacC4 enzyme likely due to 16aa extension (protein Id. AAL10408) and also in Vibrio cholerae 192aa aacA4 enzyme (protein Id. AAM52493), suggesting similar integron/plasmid involved in conjugation to transfer aacA4 genes. Certainly such extended enzymes had not proved by the protein product analysis and reflects wrong reporting as judged by plasmid mediated shorter active enzymes reported (Table 1).

Other Escherichia coli extended aac3’-IV enzymes (258aa) have several point mutations (Y188H, R236Q; WP_064770919 vs. WP_064756331) and (A53G, A216G; WP_064769430 vs. WP_064769895) and (A53G, A241R, G247E; WP_064769430 vs. WP_072833186). A genomic clone of S. enterica may code 266 aa enzyme with NH2 terminal extension of 8aa and M1V and common A53G mutations (AN:LHLZ01000022; protein Id. KNT82816). Similarly, in K. pneumoniae genome (AN: MPWC0100123 and JMXV01000021) two aacC4 enzymes (protein Ids. OKB98731 and KDJ63161) were predicted with 255 and 254 aa long and had common A53G point mutation.

Aac3’-VI enzyme of E. coli differs with single point mutations at T132S and A244V of E. cloaceae aacC6 enzyme (protein Ids. WP_053271189 vs. AAA16194) and insertions in Salmonella enterica genome may code for different acetyl transferases (protein Ids. KNK91744 and EHC71407).

Drug acetylating enzymes in expression vectors

Cat gene was introduced in many DNA vectors: As for example BAC vector pHL931 (protein Id. ALV82398); Gateway vector pB4cCGGW for plant (protein Id. BAV44483); pDONRpEX18Gm expression vector (protein Id. AJW82929); orf selection vector pSOS (protein Id. ABK62679) and so many to state. AacC1 gene (177aa) was cloned in varieties of expression vectors like pMQ175 (AN:FJ380062), pCVD001 (AN:KM017942), pSX (AN:JN703735), pUCP24 (AN:HM368668), and also in association with Beta-lactamase gene like pEX18gmGW (AN:KM880127), pLOXGen4 (AN:AJ401048); and in association with cat gene like pMpGWB236 (ANLC057515), pJM101 (AN:KX782328); and in association with AG phospho transferase gene like pBG51 (AN:KT192133) and pVZ324 (AN:AF100177). AacA4 gene (267aa) was also cloned in suicidal vector pSUI3 (AN:KX863720) and in BAC vector pHL931 (AN:KT362048) and in cloning vector pHK11-apra (AN: AJ438947) 263aa long aacA4-type gene was dissimilar at amino and carboxy terminals. Wide spread use of mdr genes in plasmids should be controlled as recombinant drug resistant bacterial isolates might be released into environment.

Discussion

We see wide spread presence of AAC enzymes in plasmids and chromosomes of household bacteria. Recently Hasani et al. evaluated aminoglycoside resistance in 87 Acinetobacter baumannii strains isolated from four hospitals of Iran and was found aac(3')-Ia predominant sequence group (SG) including ANT(2')-Ia and. APH(3')-Via. APH(3’-Ia related to resistance against amikacin and kanamycin, whereas ANT(2')-Ia was related to the resistance for gentamycin and tobramycin in SG2 and tobramycin resistance was correlated with aac(6')-Ib [92]. Many cellular N-acetyl transferases (NAT2) are known but are different than CAT and AAC enzymes.

Corynebacterium striatum BM4687 was resistant to gentamicin and tobramycin but susceptible to kanamycin A and amikacin. A novel 3-N-acetyltransferase type XI was purified and sequenced with 60% amino acid identity with acety ltransferases [93]. The purified protein acetylated dibekacin to the amine at the C-3 position Many chromosomal enzymes designated as aacA9, aacA16, aacA30, aacA41, aacA43 etc. were reported but further needed for placement [94]. Further, an unique bi-functional acetylating enzyme, aac(6’)-Ie-aph2’’-I was detected in Staphylococci cassette chromosome [95] as well as Enterococcei clinical isolates in China [93] and Campilobacter isolates in USA.

Conclusion

Thus it was concluded that drug acetyl transferases were highly diversified. Cat gene although had minimum divergence but 3’- and 6’- acetyl transferases (aacA1/C1) were arose very highly similar to very diversified β-lactamase (bla) genes (Chakraborty, 2016). Functional analysis of aminoglycoside acetyl transferases mutants, however less explored. Because such genes were associated with MBLs and acrAB/CD or mexAB/XY diverged tripartite proton drug efflux genes, Never the less, cmlA2 chloramphenicol transporter was also detected in 23kb plasmids like pRYC103T24 (AN:GQ293500; protein Id. ADC80829) of E. coli indicating chloramphenicol highly contaminated in nature and mdr gene evolution was maximum. 3-D structures and critical active site changes with better drug acetylating motifs and enlarged drugs selectivity must be addressed to design new drug against superbugs. AMR had reached an alarming label worldwide and all mdr genes must be assessed carefully at the molecular level. More importantly, three rings of aminoglycosides with many –OH and -NH2 groups of acetylation were designated as (I=1’- 6’, upper), (II=1-6, middle) and (III=1’’-6’’, lower) but the number of acetylating preferences would be determined carefully. Although drug phospho transferases and adenyl transferases could act very similarly to various O- and N-atom of the drugs but such enzymes had no similarity to aacC1 or aacA1 type enzymes indicating drug modifying enzymes indeed strongly diversified [50]. Presently, no de-acetylase enzyme was reported in MDR plasmids. Thus super conjugative plasmids with deacetylase genes could be used as a control measure to combat drug modifying superbugs that were contaminated highly in air and water. We are studying acetyl transferases in multi-drug resistant bacteria from Kolkata Ganga River and data indicates multiple isomers are present. In essence, mdr genes like drug acetyl transferases have created a very serious problem in human health and safety. It appears new drug development should be accelerated but alternate strategies like development of phyto-antibiotics, gene medicines (antisense, ribozyme, dicer-casper, miRNA) and DNA nanotechnology applications also should adapted in R&D research of India and other Asian countries with population burden.

Acknowledgement

We thank Dr. Smarajit Maity for help during the study and also thank Dr. J B Medda for financial support.

References