ISSN ONLINE(2319-8753)PRINT(2347-6710)

All submissions of the EM system will be redirected to Online Manuscript Submission System. Authors are requested to submit articles directly to Online Manuscript Submission System of respective journal.

To Analyse the Effects of Process Parameters on P-21 Mold Steel on WEDM Using Taguchi Approach

Saurabh Chhabra1, Deepak Gupta2, Parveen Yadav3
  1. Research scholar, GGGI Shahabad, Haryana, India
  2. Assistant Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering,Galaxy global group of institution, shahabad, Haryana, India.
  3. Assistant Professor, Chandigarh University, Punjab, India
  4. Assistant Professor, Chandigarh University, Punjab, India
Related article at Pubmed, Scholar Google

Visit for more related articles at International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology

Abstract

Wire Electric discharge machine is a specialized thermal machining process capable of accurately machining parts with varying hardness and complex shapes. The material P-21 used in the present work study finds out the application as mould steel. The main aim of this investigation is to optimize the various process parameters of WEDM for single response characteristics using L18 orthogonal array to find out the performance characteristics from desired value. The present work was carried out on P-21 mould steel as work piece and zinc coated brass wire as tool electrode. Response characteristics are cutting speed and surface roughness. Three trial experiments were conducted and the average is chosen as the particular experimental condition. Experiment were performed by using different variables like input current, pulse-on, pulse-off, wire feed and wire tension. In the end confirmation experiment is carried out to validate the effectiveness of proposed optimal condition

Keywords

P-21, WEDM, L18 orthogonal array, S/N ratio, ANOVA

I. INTRODUCTION

WEDM is a metal removing machine in which the electrode used is the continuous moving wire of Copper (Cu) and Brass. This is fed into the work-piece from the supply pool to take-up-pool. This continuous moving wire does not come in contact with the conductive work material. The material is eroded from the work-piece by discrete spark between the work-piece and electrode and these are separated by dielectric fluid. The gap between the work-piece and electrode is usually upto 0.0025-0.015mm and is maintained with the help of computer control WEDM. The important step is the selection of process parameter if improper process parameter are selected then it may result in problem i.e wire breakage, short circuiting of wire. No of studies has been carried out on various responses like material removal rate, surface roughness, cutting speed which depend upon various parameters like pulse-on, pulse-off, input current and many more.
WEDM is a metal removing machine in which the electrode used is the continuous moving wire of Copper (Cu) and Brass. This is fed into the work-piece from the supply pool to take-up-pool. This continuous moving wire does not come in contact with the conductive work material. The material is eroded from the work-piece by discrete spark between the work-piece and electrode and these are separated by dielectric fluid. The gap between the work-piece and electrode is usually upto 0.0025-0.015mm and is maintained with the help of computer control WEDM. The important step is the selection of process parameter if improper process parameter are selected then it may result in problem i.e wire breakage, short circuiting of wire. No of studies has been carried out on various responses like material removal rate, surface roughness, cutting speed which depend upon various parameters like pulse-on, pulse-off, input current and many more.
image

II. EXPERIMENTAL SET-UP AND SELECTION OF PROCESS PARAMETERS

The pulse generator capacity of the machine is 40A. The pulse generator supplies the electrical energy to the spark gap in the form of pulses. The machine tool unit comprises of a main worktable (called X-Y table) by which the work piece is clamped on auxiliary table (called U-V table) and wire drive mechanism. Figure 2. shows the stepwise procedure for Taguchi experimental design and analysis. Figure 3. shows the experiments are carried out in CNC sprint cut wire EDM of Electronic a Machine tool ltd.
image
Work piece Electrode: - The work piece material used in this investigation was steel P-21 Mould steel. Composition of P-21 Mould steel is C= 0.18-0.22% , Mn= 0.20-0.40% , Si ≤0.030% ,Cr= 0.50-0.30%, Ni=3.90-4.25%, Si= 0.20- 0.40%, P≤ 0.030, V= 0.15-0.25, Al = 1.05-1.25. A P-21 die Mould steel plate of size 200x50x20 (l x b x w) is used.
Tool Electrode: Zinc coated copper wire having dia of 0.25mm is used in the present investigation as the electrode. Zinc coated Copper wire electrode can conduct high current as compare to simple copper wire.

Selection of Process Parameters and their Ranges:

In order to obtain high cutting speed, accurate dimension, better quality of surface roughness and the Good Material removal rate can be obtained by WEDM process. The optimal level of WEDM process parameters need to be determined. Based on the critical review of literature, process variables of the WEDM are selected according to transient state.
The process parameters selected for this study are as following:
a. Current.
b. Pulse- ON time.
c. Pulse-OFF time.
d. Wire Speed
e. Wire Tension
In Sprint-cut WEDM, the value of current ranges b/w 10 to 230A, Pulse-ON time b/w 110 to 131, Pulse-OFF varies b/w 0-63, Wire speed 1-15m/min and Wire tension ranges between1 to 15N.

III. SELECTION OF ORTHOGONAL ARRAY (OA) AND PARAMETER ASSIGNMENT

\Before selecting a particular OA to be used as a matrix for conducting the experiments, the following two points are first considered:
1. The number of parameters and interactions of interest.
2. The number of levels for the parameters of interest.
Degree of freedom (DOF) associated with each factor is equal to no. of level -1. Therefore, total degree of freedom for the five factors is (5+2+2+2+2) 11. As per Taguchi’s method, the total DOF of selected OA must be greater than or equal to the total DOF required for the experiment. So, L18 OA having 17 (=18-1) degree of freedom is selected for the present analysis. The experiments are conducted at each trial conditions as given in table 2. For each trial, the experiments is repeated by three times.
image
image

IV. RESULT AND DISCUSSION

In this section, we are discussing the effect of WEDM process parameters( peak current, pulse on time, pulse off time, current, wire speed and wire tension) on the basis of response characteristics(cutting speed and surface roughness). The average value of response characteristics, mean data and S/N ratio for each parameter, at all levels, is calculated from table 3. These effects are plotted by using MINITAB 15 SOFTWARE.

Effect Of Parameters On Cutting Speed

Average value of Cutting speed calculated from raw data is 3.71 mm/min. It is clear from the S/N plots. That the maximum S/N ratio occurs correspond to A6,B3,C1,D1,E3.Therefore, the optimum value will correspond to these factors but only the significant factor would be chosen. This factor will be chosen from the ANOVA table.
image
image
image
image

Effect of Parameters On Surface Roughness

Surface roughness is a key factor in die making and depends upon the energy drop across the electrodes. Surface roughness is a “smaller is better” type characteristics. So, the optimum value of surface roughness should be low so that depth of recast layer remains minimum or equal to zero. Average value of surface roughness is 2.83μm. Main effects of each parameter are calculated from response table 5 and 6 as shown in fig 2. These effects are plotted by using MINITAB 15.
image
image
image
image

Confirmation Experiment:

It is conducted for the cutting speed, die width and for surface roughness. The experimental value obtained at the optimal setting of parameter is:
Cutting speed = 3.56 mm/min
Surface roughness = 3.13μm.

V. CONCLUSION

On the basis of above studied experiments, it can be safely concluding that:- .
• Cutting Speed is affected by Pulse-on and Pulse-off time
• Surface roughness does not have any significant factor

References

  1.  Pichai janmance, Apiwat Muttamara “ Optimization of electrical discharge machining of composite 900WC-10Co base on Taguchi approach” European journal of scientific research Vol. 64 No. 3 (2011), pp 426-436
  2. Pujari srinivasa, Kooma Ramji, Beela Satyanarayana. Effect of WEDM conditions on surface roughness:A Parametric optimisation using Taguchi Method: international journal of advanced engineering sciences amd technologies Vol No-6, PP-41-48 (2011).
  3.   V.Muthuraman, R.Ramakrishnan, L.Kartikeyan, C.Parveen. Influences of process variables during wire electric discharge machining of O1 Steel: European journal of scientific research. Vol79 no 3 pp 449-456 (2012).
  4. Anish kumar, Vinod Kumar, Jatinder Kumar. Prediction of surface roughness in wire electric discharge machining(WEDM) process based on response surface methodology: international journal of engineering and technology. Vol 2 No. 4 pp-708-719 (2012).
  5. Aniza Alias, Bulan Abdullah, Nonliana Mohd. Abbas. Influence Of machine feed rate in WEDM of titanium Ti-6AL-4V with constant current (6A) using brass wire: International Symposium on Robotics and intelligent sensors(2012) procedia engineering 41 pp-1806-1811.
  6. Aniza Alias, Bulan Abdullah, Nonliana Mohd. Abbas. WEDM: International Symposium on Robotics and intelligent sensors(2012) procedia engineering 41pp-1812-1817.
  7. Jaganathan P, naveen Kumar T, Dr. R. Sivasubramanian “ Machining parameters optimization of WEDM process using Taguchi method” International journal of scientific and research publication Vol. 2