ISSN: 2319-9873

Reach Us +44 7456 035580
All submissions of the EM system will be redirected to Online Manuscript Submission System. Authors are requested to submit articles directly to Online Manuscript Submission System of respective journal.

Flexural Strength of Concrete by Partial Replacement of Sand with Basic Oxygen Furnace Slag

Musawir Quadir*

School of Architecture, Jammu and Kashmir, India

*Corresponding Author:
Musawir Quadir
Assistant Professor
School of Architecture
Jammu and Kashmir, India
E-mail: musawiroo@gmail.com

Received Date: 04/01/2018; Accepted Date: 25/02/2018; Published Date: 30/03/2018

Visit for more related articles at Research & Reviews: Journal of Engineering and Technology

Abstract

This research work evaluates the use of Basic oxygen furnace slag as a replacement for fine aggregates, in M-25 grade of concrete. The fine aggregates were partially replaced, by weight with Basic oxygen furnace slag. The prepared mixes were named as Mix-A, Mix-B, Mix-C and Mix-D. The mixes were prepared at 0%, 15%, 25% and 35% replacement levels respectively. All the mixes were fabricated at 0.46 water cement ratio. To study the behaviour and response of beam members, casted with above said composition, in flexure, the tests performed after 7 and 28 days on beam specimens and the composite mix prepared, were flexural strength test, density and slump test. IS standards were followed while conducting the above captioned tests. The obtained results were compared with those of controlled M-25 concrete mix. The investigated results found, vary according to proportions of supplementary constituents added to the M-25 concrete mix. The substitution of Basic oxygen furnace slag enhances the Flexural strength of M-25 concrete mix up to certain percentage. After adding 15% Basic Oxygen furnace slag in the mix, there is an increase of 17.67% strength after 7 days, and 17.26% increase after 28 days. The Flexural strength increases as compared to control mix as the percentage of Basic Oxygen furnace slag is increased. At 25% addition of Basic Oxygen furnace slag in the mix, there is an increase of 28.37% strength after 7 days, and 23.31% increase after 28 days. A decline in Flexural strength as compared to control mix was observed when the percentage of Basic Oxygen furnace slag was increased to 35%. A decrease by 3.16% was observed after 7 days, and 16.42% decrease after 28 days. Slump and unit weight of thus manufactured concrete also increases with the addition of Basic oxygen furnace slag to it. Thus Basic oxygen furnace slag can be successfully used in concrete, to improve flexural strength, slump values and weight of concrete as wells.

Keywords

Oxygen furnace, Slag, Natural aggregates

Introduction

Production of residues from industries and construction sector has increased during last few years. Much of these wastes have been thrown to land fill, without considering its potential for reuse and re-cycling as well [1].

Basic Oxygen Furnace slag is formed during the conversion of hot metal from the blast furnace into steel in a basic oxygen furnace (Figure 1). In this process the hot metal is treated by blowing oxygen to remove carbon and other elements that have a high affinity to oxygen. The slag (Figure 2) is generated by the addition of fluxes, such as lime stone or dolomite that combines with silicates and oxides to form liquid slag. Some amounts of scrap are also added in order to control the temperature of the exothermal reactions [2].

engineering-and-technology-oxygen

Figure 1: Basic oxygen furnace.

engineering-and-technology-furnace

Figure 2: Basic oxygen furnace slag.

When the reaction process is complete, molten crude steel collects on the bottom of the furnace and the liquid slag floats on top of it (Table 1). The crude steel and the slag are tapped into separate ladles/pots at temperatures typically above 1600°C. After tapping, the liquid slag in the pot can further be treated by injection of SiO2 and oxygen in order to increase volume stability. The molten slag is then poured into pits or ground bays where it air-cools under controlled conditions forming crystalline slag [3]. In order to adjust the required technical properties for a specific use, different measures like weathering, crushing and sieving are performed on the crystalline slag (Figures 3 and 4).

engineering-and-technology-slag

Figure 3: EDS graph of basic oxygen furnace slag.

engineering-and-technology-electron

Figure 4: Electron image of basic oxygen furnace slag.

Table 1. Composition of basic oxygen furnace slag.

Element Weight% Atomic%
C 8.85 15.87
O 44.29 59.63
Mg 0.44 0.39
Al 8.57 6.84
Si 6.15 4.72
Ca 0.79 0.42
Ti 0.64 0.29
Cr 4.24 1.76
Mn 6.10 2.39
Fe 19.92 7.68

Materials and Methods

The selection of aggregate material is important as aggregates control concrete properties and make up 60% - 75% of the total concrete volume. Hence careful attention should be given in the selection and proportioning of aggregates [4].

Materials

The materials were used in the test program; Ordinary Portland Cement, Natural coarse aggregate, Basic oxygen furnace slag, Sand and Water. Material properties are as under [5]:

Cement

Ordinary Portland cement of 43 grades was used throughout the investigation. The cement was available in the local market Ambala City and kept in dry location [6]. The tests were conducted to determine the properties of cement (Table 2).

Table 2. Physical properties of ordinary portland cement.

S.No Property Results
1 Fineness 3%
2 Soundness 1 mm
3 Setting time Initial =95min, Final = 165 min
4 Specific gravity 3.15
5 Compressive strength After 7 days=33.2MPa
After 28 days=44.32 MPa

Water

Tap water, potable without any salts or chemicals was used in the study. The water source was the concrete laboratory in Ram Devi Jindal College.

Natural aggregates

In this study, both coarse and fine aggregates were used to prepare a controlled as well as Basic oxygen furnace slag added concrete (Tables 3-5). The various physical properties of coarse aggregates and fine aggregates were investigated using IS: 383- 1970 (Table 6 and Figures 5 and 6).

Table 3. Sieve analysis of natural coarse aggregate with max. sizeof 20mm 3kg sample (IS:383-1970).

Sieve size Material retained (gm) Percentage retained Cumulative % age passing Cumulative % age retained
80 mm 0 0.00 100 0.00
40 mm 0 0.00 100 0.00
20 mm 68.5 2.28 97.72 2.28
10 mm 2776.5 92.55 5.17 94.83
4.75 mm 113.5 3.78 1.38 98.62
2.36 mm 0 0.00 0.00 100
1.18 mm 0 0.00 0.00 100
600 µ 0 0.00 0.00 100
300 µ 0 0.00 0.00 100
150 µ 0 0.00 0.00 100
Pan 0 0.00 - -
Sum 3000   Sum 695.73
FM 6.95

Table 4. Physical properties of natural coarse aggregates.

Characteristics Value
Colour Grey
Shape Angular
Maximum size 20mm
Specific Gravity 2.64
Total water absorption 1.01%
Fineness Modulus 6.96

Table 5. Sieve analysis of natural fine aggregates (1 kg) as per IS 383-1970.

Sieve Size Material retained (in gm) Retained %age Cumulative %age passing Cumulative %age retained
4.75 mm 14.5 1.45 98.55 1.45
2.36 mm 37 3.70 94.85 5.15
1.18 mm 246.5 24.65 70.20 29.80
600µ 205.5 20.55 49.65 50.35
300µ 287.5 28.75 20.90 79.10
150µ 177 17.70 3.20 96.80
Pan 32 3.20 - -
Sum 1000   Sum 262.65
FM 2.62

Table 6. Physical properties of natural fine aggregate.

Characteristics Value
Water absorption 2.04
Fineness modulus 2.63
Bulk density 2.60
Specific Gravity 2.57
engineering-and-technology-cumulative

Figure 5: Graph of sieve size versus cumulative percentage passing of coarse aggregate.

engineering-and-technology-percentage

Figure 6: Graph of sieve size versus cumulative percentage passing of fine aggregate.

Basic oxygen furnace slag

The Basic oxygen furnace slag and was collected from Bassi steel ltd and JTL Infrastructure ltd (Tables 7-9 and Figure 7).

Table 7. Sieve analysis of basic oxygen furnace slag.

Sieve Size Material retained in gms Retained %age Cumulative %age passing Cumulative %age retained
4.75 mm 22 2.2 97.8 2.2
2.36 mm 51 5.1 92.7 7.3
1.18 mm 165 16.5 76.2 23.80
600 µ 247 24.7 51.5 48.50
300 µ 279 27.9 23.6 76.40
150 µ 137 13.7 9.9 90.10
Pan 93 9.3 - -
Sum 1000 - Sum 248.3
FM 2.48

Table 8. Physical properties of Basic oxygen furnace slag.

Characteristics Value
Water absorption 0.40
Fineness modulus 2.48
Specific Gravity 2.69
engineering-and-technology-basic

Figure 7: Graph of sieve size versus cumulative percentage passing of basic oxygen furnace slag.

Mix proportions

Table 9. Mix-proportions of different mixes

Material Description Material source Mix-Akg/m3 Mix-B kg/m3 Mix-C kg/m3 Mix-D kg/m3
Cement (OPC) 43 Grade Ambala City 418 418 418 418
Natural Fine sand Pathankot sand ( Zone II ) 660 561 495 429
Natural coarse Aggregate Handesra stone crusher 1105 1105 1105 1105
Basic Oxygen furnace slag Derabassi, Bassi steel ltd Nil 99 165 231
Water cement ratio - 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46
Free Water RDJ lab water 192 192 192 192
Ratios(Cement: Sand: BOF-Slag: Coarse aggregate) - 1:1.27:0:2.64 1:1.34:0.21:2.64 1:1.18:0.39:2.64 1:1.02:0.55:2.64

Results and Discussion

Slump

The slump increases with the increase in the percentage of Basic oxygen furnace slag in the concrete and reaches a maximum of 72 mm at 35% replacement of sand with basic oxygen furnace slag [7-9], when compared with control mix of concrete (Table 10 and Figures 8 and 9).

Table 10. Slump values obtained.

Mix % age Replacement of fine Aggregate Slump (mm)
Control mix(Mix A) 0% 58
M25BOF-Slag(Mix B) 15% 63
M25BOF-Slag(Mix C) 25% 68
M25BOF-Slag(Mix D) 35% 72
engineering-and-technology-test

Figure 8: Slump test.

engineering-and-technology-levels

Figure 9: Slump versus material graph at various %age levels.

Density of Mixes

The average weight of control mix is 8.15 kg [10]. As the percentage of Basic oxygen furnace slag increases subsequently the average weight of all the fabricated mixes increase and reaches a maximum of 8.858 kg in Mix-D (Table 11).

Table 11. Densities of various mix proportions.

  Particulars Age of cubes (days) %age Replacement of fine Aggregate Average Weight (kg) Volume of Cubes (m3) Mass Density of Concrete (Kg/m3)
Control mix (Mix A) 28 0% 7.84 0.003375 2323
M25BOF-Slag (Mix B) 28 15% 8.21 0.003375 2432.6
M25BOF-Slag (Mix C) 28 25% 8.428 0.003375 2497.2
M25BOF-Slag (Mix D) 28 35% 8.858 0.003375 2624.59

The variation in densities of different mixes is shown graphically in Figure 10.

engineering-and-technology-versus

Figure 10: Density versus material graph at various %age levels.

Flexural Strength

This test was performed on the Beam samples at the age of 7 and 28 days. Figure 11 shows the test results of controlled and treated specimens at 7 and 28 days with 15% replacement of fine aggregate with Basic Oxygen furnace [11-13]. The 7 days and 28 days results are presented in Table 12.

engineering-and-technology-flexural

Figure 11: Comparison of flexural strength of M-25 control mix with basic oxygen furnace slag added concrete.

Table 12. Flexural strength test results for the beam samples (700 x 150 mm x 150mm).

MIX Basic Oxygen Furnace Slag
Flexural strength (kg/cm2) Average flexural strength (kg/cm2)
A 7 Days 28 Days 7 Days 28 Days
58.30 70.23 54.94 65.57
56.37 65.54
50.15 60.96
B 64.42 77.78 64.65 76.89
68.60 76.25
60.95 76.66
C 70.13 80.42 70.53 80.86
70.54 80.83
70.94 81.34
D 54.23 57.28 53.20 54.80
54.12 56.27
51.27 50.86

Flexural Strength In %Age After Adding Basic Oxygen Furnace Slag

The Flexural strength decrease as compared to control mix (Mix-A) as the percentage of Basic Oxygen furnace slag is increased [14,15]. After adding 35% Basic Oxygen furnace slag in the mix, a decrease in flexural strength by 3.16% was observed after 7 days (Figure 12) and 16.42% decrease after 28 days (Figure 13). The %age of flexural strength decreases at 35% replacement level [16].

engineering-and-technology-concrete

Figure 12: Percentage increase in 7 days flexural strength of basic oxygen furnace slag added concrete at various percentage levels.

engineering-and-technology-percentage

Figure 13: Percentage increase in 28 days flexural strength basic oxygen furnace slag added concrete at various percentage levels.

Conclusion

Workablity

From the Slump test results, the concrete produced with Basic Oxygen furnace slag gives higher values of slump i.e., 72 mm at 35% replacement level than controlled M-25 grade concrete, prepared with 0% replacement of sand.

Density

From the obtained values of density, Basic Oxygen furnace slag based concrete gives greater density than controlled M-25 grade of concrete and gives a maximum value 2497.2 kg/m3 at 35% replacement.

Flexural Strength

• At 15% and 25% replacement by weight of fine aggregate with Basic Oxygen furnace slag, a remarkable achievement in flexural strength was observed.

• When the percentage of replacement, is increased to 35%, the flexural strength decreases abruptly.

• The 7 days flexural strength increased by 17.67%, 28.37%, in case of Basic Oxygen furnace slag based concrete at 15%, 25% replacement levels respectively and decreases by 3.16% and 6.18% at 35% replacement level.

• The 28 days flexural strength increased by 17.26%, 23.31% in case of Basic Oxygen furnace slag based concrete at 15%, 25% replacement levels respectively and decreases by 16.42% and 20.13% at 35% replacement level.

• Hence it could be recommended that Basic Oxygen furnace slag could be effectively utilized as fine aggregates in all concrete applications, upto certain replacement levels of fine aggregate as discussed in the results to improve the strength of concrete in Flexure.

References